State of U.P. v. Jai Bir Singh
Supreme Court of India · 2026 INSC 897 · Bench: Surya Kant CJI, B.V. Nagarathna J., P.S. Narasimha J., Dipankar Datta J., Ujjal Bhuyan J., Satish Chandra Sharma J., Joymalya Bagchi J., Alok Aradhe J., Vipul M. Pancholi J. (9-Judge Bench)
- Decided: 2026-08-20
- Subject: Labour Law
- Provisions: Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Section 2(j); Industrial Relations Code, 2020, Section 2(p)
- Outcome: No Conclusive Majority — Bangalore Water Supply Standard Retained
- Good-law status: Good Law
Facts
A decades-old 2002 reference questioned the correctness of the expansive "industry" definition from Bangalore Water Supply, given conflicting subsequent rulings and the enactment of the Industrial Relations Code, 2020.
Issue
Whether the "triple test" laid down in Bangalore Water Supply v. A. Rajappa (1978) for defining "industry" under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 required reconsideration, and how it interacts with the newer definition under the Industrial Relations Code, 2020.
Held
A fractured nine-judge bench delivered no clear majority — four judges favoured a reformulated test proposed by the CJI, four affirmed Bangalore Water Supply, and one decided on a different ground — leaving the Bangalore Water Supply standard operative for pending disputes, with any new test applying only prospectively.
Ratio decidendi
In the absence of a clear majority on reformulating a foundational precedent, the existing precedent continues to govern pending matters; new interpretive tests, if any, operate only prospectively.
Exam notes
A landmark labour law case — pair directly with Bangalore Water Supply v. A. Rajappa (1978) for judiciary/PCS-J mains; also a rare example of a fractured large-bench verdict, useful for constitutional bench procedure questions.