Pathmavathi v. Bharthi Axa General Insurance

Supreme Court of India · Supreme Court of India, 2026, February judgment reference 132 · Bench: Dipankar Datta; S

  • Decided: 2026-01-13
  • Subject: Tax law; Motor accident compensation
  • Provisions: General legal principles and statutory framework discussed in the decision.
  • Outcome: Legal principle laid down; operative relief as per Supreme Court decision.
  • Good-law status: Good law unless modified by a later binding Supreme Court decision.

Facts

The Supreme Court has expressed reservations about the Constitution Bench ruling in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017), which excludes non-pecuniary loss arising from deprivation of “love and affection” as a separate head while determining compensation in motor accident cases. In Pranay Sethi, it was held that non- pecuniary damages should be awarded only under three conventional heads, i.e., loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses.

Issue

Whether supreme Court Expresses Reservations About CB Judgment That 'Loss Of Love & Affection' Can't Be Separately Compensated In Motor Accident Claims?

Held

The Supreme Court has expressed reservations about the Constitution Bench ruling in National Insurance Co.

Ratio decidendi

The Supreme Court has expressed reservations about the Constitution Bench ruling in National Insurance Co.

Dissent

No dissent recorded.

Exam notes

Remember: Tax law; Motor accident compensation; General legal principles and statutory framework discussed in the decision.; Supreme Court Expresses Reservations About CB Judgment That 'Loss Of Love & Affection' Can't Be Separately Compensated In Motor Accident Claims.

Source: https://www.sci.gov.in/judgements/?keyword=Pathmavathi+%26+Ors.+v.+Bharthi+Axa+General+Insurance+Co.+Ltd+%26+Anr.