Municipal Corporation of Greater v. R.V.

Supreme Court of India · EL-SC-2026-03-031 · Bench: Supreme Court of India

  • Decided: 2026-03
  • Subject: Arbitration law
  • Provisions: General legal principles applied by the Supreme Court
  • Outcome: Supreme Court disposed of the matter in terms of the stated legal principle.
  • Good-law status: Good law unless modified by a later binding Supreme Court decision.

Facts

The Supreme Court has observed that a party which participates in arbitration proceedings without raising a jurisdictional objection at the appropriate stage cannot subsequently raise a technical plea of jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal upon passing of an adverse award. Chandurkar, while upholding an arbitral award, which was sought to be challenged by the Appellant by raising a technical plea of jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal, when an adverse award was passed against it. Ltd. v. Bihar Rajya Pul Nirman Nigam Ltd, 2025 (SC) 1153.

Issue

Whether arbitration Belated Jurisdictional Challenge Impermissible After Active Participation In Arbitration Proceedings?

Held

The Supreme Court has observed that a party which participates in arbitration proceedings without raising a jurisdictional objection at the appropriate stage cannot subsequently raise a technical plea of jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal upon passing of an adverse award.

Ratio decidendi

A party cannot keep a 'jurisdictional ace' up their sleeve and then claim that filing of the jurisdictional challenge under Section 16 would go back in time and wipe out the past conduct and acquiescence of the party which would clearly evince how the contractual terms were viewed by the parties. If the same is permitted, it will erode the basic principles of alternative dispute resolution and ethos of arbitration.

Dissent

No dissent recorded.

Exam notes

Remember: Arbitration law; General legal principles applied by the Supreme Court; Arbitration Belated Jurisdictional Challenge Impermissible After Active Participation In Arbitration Proceedings Supreme Court.

Source: https://www.sci.gov.in/judgements/?keyword=Municipal+Corporation+of+Greater+Mumbai+v.+M%2FS+R.V.+Anderson+Associates+Limited