RAHUL AGARWAL v. THE BENGAL

Supreme Court of India · C.A. NO. 004456-004456 - 2025 · Bench: Justice B. R. Gavai, Justice K. Vinod Chandran

  • Subject: Criminal Law — General
  • Provisions: See Digest Summary
  • Outcome: Set Aside
  • Good-law status: Good Law

Facts

A Judicial Magistrate can order a person, including a witness, to provide a voice sample for investigation, despite the absence of specific provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code. This action does not constitute "testimonial compulsion" and does not infringe on the right against self-incrimination under Article 20(3) of the Constitution. The High Court's order that set aside the Magistrate's decision has been reversed, and the witness is directed to comply with the Magistrate's order. Pending applications related to this matter have also been disposed of.

Issue

Legal question arising in criminal law — general

Held

A Judicial Magistrate can order a person, including a witness, to provide a voice sample for investigation, despite the absence of specific provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code.

Ratio decidendi

A Judicial Magistrate can order a person, including a witness, to provide a voice sample for investigation, despite the absence of specific provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code.

Source: https://indiankanoon.org/search/?formInput=RAHUL%20AGARWAL%20VS%20THE%20STATE%20OF%20WEST%20BENGAL%20C.A.%20NO.%20004456-004456%20-%202025