APEEJAY SCHOOL v. DHRITI DUGGAL

Supreme Court of India · SMW(CRL) NO. 010055-010055 - 2025 · Bench: Justice B. R. Gavai, Justice K. Vinod Chandran, Justice N. V. Anjaria

  • Decided: 2025-08-05
  • Subject: Taxation — Direct & Indirect
  • Provisions: See Digest Summary
  • Outcome: Allowed
  • Good-law status: Good Law

Facts

There is no express or implied ouster of civil court jurisdiction regarding the recovery of fees charged by private schools. The Haryana School Education Act and Rules provide a remedy for students or parents to challenge capitation fees, not for schools to enforce fee payment. The suits for the recovery of fee increases were not barred by limitation, as the cause of action arose after the state's appeal related to a previous judgment was resolved. The trial court's decision to condition the recovery decree on the FFRC's ruling was appropriate, offering protection against excessive fee levies. However, the appellate court's requirement for a complete refund if the FFRC rules in favor of students or parents was incorrect; refunds should only occur to the degree the FFRC modifies the fee hike. The school's civil appeals were allowed, restoring the trial court's order with an adjustment to the interest rate. IN RE : SUMMONING ADVOCATES WHO GIVE LEGAL OPINION OR REPRESENT PARTIES DURING

Issue

Legal question arising in taxation — direct & indirect

Held

There is no express or implied ouster of civil court jurisdiction regarding the recovery of fees charged by private schools.

Ratio decidendi

There is no express or implied ouster of civil court jurisdiction regarding the recovery of fees charged by private schools.

Source: https://indiankanoon.org/search/?formInput=APEEJAY%20SCHOOL%20VS%20DHRITI%20DUGGAL%20SMW%28CRL%29%20NO.%20010055-010055%20-%202025