THE PRADESH v. JANVED SINGH

Supreme Court of India · C.A. NO. 000460-000460 - 2014 · Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar, Justice Alok Aradhe Justice Sanjay Kumar, Justice Alok Aradhe

  • Decided: 2025-03-21
  • Subject: Taxation — Direct & Indirect
  • Provisions: See Digest Summary
  • Outcome: Set Aside; Quashed; Restored; Reinstated
  • Good-law status: Good Law

Facts

The High Court's judgment of acquittal was set aside, and the conviction and sentence of Janved Singh were restored. The prosecution presented a complete chain of circumstances indicating his guilt, including medical evidence of homicidal death, the accused's false account of events, and his inability to explain the death that occurred in his residence. The reasons for acquittal were deemed erroneous and unsupported by the evidence. NOVENCO BUILDING AND INDUSTRY A/S VS XERO ENERGY ENGINEERING SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED [C.A. NO.-013019- 013019 - 2025] In a case of continuing infringement of intellectual property rights, urgency for interim relief must be evaluated from the plaintiff's perspective based on the plaint and supporting documents. Delay in filing does not negate urgency when infringement is ongoing, as each act of infringement constitutes a new wrong. Examining entitlement to urgent relief based on merits instead of evidence of urgency was incorrect. The previous orders were quashed, and the commercial suit was reinstated for merits consideration following established principles.

Issue

Whether acquittal by lower court is sustainable?

Held

The High Court's judgment of acquittal was set aside, and the conviction and sentence of Janved Singh were restored.

Ratio decidendi

The High Court's judgment of acquittal was set aside, and the conviction and sentence of Janved Singh were restored.

Source: https://indiankanoon.org/search/?formInput=THE%20STATE%20OF%20MADHYA%20PRADESH%20VS%20JANVED%20SINGH%20C.A.%20NO.%20000460-000460%20-%202014