IN THIRUMULPAD v. UNION INDIA

Supreme Court of India · C.A. NO. 000202-000202 - 1995 · Bench: Justice B.R. Gavai, Justice Augustine George Masih

  • Subject: Taxation — Direct & Indirect
  • Provisions: See Digest Summary
  • Outcome: Quashed
  • Good-law status: Good Law

Facts

The Court held that the performance appraisal reports (PARs) of Indian Forest Service (IFS) officers up to the rank of Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (APCCF) must be written by their immediate superior officers within the Forest Department, as their "reporting authority" and "reviewing authority". The court found the Madhya Pradesh government's order providing for involvement of non-Forest Department officers in writing PARs to be in violation of the court's previous rulings, and consequently quashed the impugned order, directing the state to reframe the rules in accordance with the court's directions. The court noted that except Madhya Pradesh, other states were already following its previous orders on this matter.

Issue

Whether review is maintainable?

Held

The Court held that the performance appraisal reports (PARs) of Indian Forest Service (IFS) officers up to the rank of Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (APCCF) must be written by their immediate superior officers within the Forest Department, as their "reporting authority" and "reviewing authority".

Ratio decidendi

The Court held that the performance appraisal reports (PARs) of Indian Forest Service (IFS) officers up to the rank of Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (APCCF) must be written by their immediate superior officers within the Forest Department, as their "reporting authority" and "reviewing authority".

Source: https://indiankanoon.org/search/?formInput=IN%20RE%20%3A%20T.N.%20GODAVARMAN%20THIRUMULPAD%20VS%20UNION%20OF%20INDIA%20C.A.%20NO.%20000202-000202%20-%201995