Shaifali Gupta v. Vidya Devi

Supreme Court of India · 2025 INSC 739 · Bench: To be verified

  • Decided: 2025-06-16
  • Subject: Partition Suit - Benami Transactions - Order VII Rule 11
  • Provisions: Order VII Rule 11 CPC; Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988
  • Outcome: Appeal dismissed. Plait upheld for trial.
  • Good-law status: Good Law

Facts

Partition suit seeking division of joint family property. Defendants sought rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11(d) claiming bar under Benami Act.

Issue

Whether partition suit can be dismissed at preliminary stage when exception to Benami Act is pleaded

Held

Partition suit cannot be dismissed under Order VII Rule 11 at preliminary stage when plaintiff invokes exception to Benami Transactions Act. Determining whether properties are benami or joint family assets involves factual inquiries requiring trial. When exception pleaded, plaint cannot be rejected at pleading stage.

Ratio decidendi

Partition suit cannot be dismissed under Order VII Rule 11 at preliminary stage when plaintiff invokes exception to Benami Transactions Act. Determining whether properties are benami or joint family a...

Exam notes

Key case on Partition Suit - Benami Transactions - Order VII Rule 11