L. Chandra Kumar v Union of India
Supreme Court of India · AIR 1997 SC 1125 · Bench: 7-judge bench: Ahmadi CJ, Verma J, Punchhi J, Anand J, Majmudar J, Bharucha J, Kirpal J
- Decided: 1997-03-18
- Subject: Constitutional Law — Judicial Review — Article 323B — Basic Structure
- Provisions: Constitution — Articles 32, 226, 227, 323A, 323B; Administrative Tribunals Act 1985; Forty-Second Amendment
- Outcome: Partly Allowed
- Good-law status: Good Law
Facts
Articles 323A and 323B (inserted by 42nd Amendment) established Administrative Tribunals and excluded the jurisdiction of High Courts under Articles 226 and 227 over service matters. The constitutional validity of this exclusion was challenged.
Issue
Whether Parliament can oust High Court/Supreme Court jurisdiction over administrative tribunal decisions through constitutional amendment.
Held
The power of judicial review over legislative and executive action is a basic feature of the Constitution and cannot be ousted. Administrative Tribunals can function as courts of first instance but the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and High Courts cannot be excluded. Clause 2(d) of Article 323A and clause 3(d) of Article 323B which excluded High Court jurisdiction are unconstitutional.
Ratio decidendi
Judicial review by the superior courts (High Courts under Articles 226/227 and Supreme Court under Article 32) is a basic structure element of the Constitution and cannot be abrogated by constitutional amendment or statute.
Exam notes
Judicial review = basic structure. Administrative Tribunals are valid but must have HC/SC appellate supervision. Complements Kesavananda and Minerva Mills.