Vishal Tiwari v. Union of India

Supreme Court · 2025 EduLaw (SC) 547 · Not expressly dated in source; verify against certified judgment before quoting exact date

Bench: CJI Sanjiv Khanna; Sanjay Kumar

Contempt; judiciary

FACTS: The bench was dealing with a PIL seeking suo motu criminal contempt proceedings against the MP and registration of FIRs against hate speeches in the context of the Waqf Amendment Act 2025. The Court held that the Constitution is higher than all and judicial review is a constitutional function, debunking parliamentary supremacy claims. ISSUE: Whether comments attacking the judiciary and CJI warrant contempt proceedings? RULING: The Supreme Court strongly deprecated comments made by a BJP MP attacking the judiciary and the Chief Justice of India, terming them highly irresponsible and attention-seeking, but refrained from taking action saying public confidence in the judiciary cannot be shaken by such absurd comments. REASONING: Public confidence in the judiciary cannot be shaken by such absurd comments; the Constitution is higher than all and judicial review is a constitutional function. SIGNIFICANCE: Remember: Contempt; judiciary; Highly Irresponsible Comments Against Judiciary & CJI Deprecated; Judicial Review A Constitutional Function. DISSENT: No dissent noted

Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam

All court updates