Vidyawant v. State of Maharashtra
Supreme Court · 2026 INSC 510 · 2026-05-19
Bench: Justice M.M. Sundresh, Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh
Preventive Detention - MPDA Act - Public Order vs Law and Order
FACTS: Appellant was detained under MPDA Act as bootlegger. Five cases registered under Maharashtra Prohibition Act but no effort made to arrest under ordinary criminal law. No material showing breach of public order. ISSUE: Whether preventive detention sustainable when accused can be dealt with under ordinary criminal law? RULING: Preventive detention requires cogent material demonstrating activities disrupted public order, not merely law and order. Where person can be dealt with under ordinary criminal law, preventive detention is unwarranted. REASONING: Preventive detention requires proof of public order disturbance; ordinary law must be exhausted first. SIGNIFICANCE: Detention Order Quashed