Shyamal Ghosh v. State of West Bengal
Supreme Court · 2012 INSC 281; MANU/SC/0544/2012; (2012) 7 SCC 646 · 2012-05-01
Bench: J. H.L. Dattu, J. Chandramauli Kumar Prasad
Criminal Law / POCSO
FACTS: In a POCSO case, the conviction of the accused rested primarily on "last seen together" evidence — witnesses who saw the accused with the minor victim shortly before the offence was alleged. There was no direct or forensic evidence linking the accused to the crime. The accused appealed against conviction. ISSUE: Whether "last seen together" evidence alone is sufficient to sustain a conviction under POCSO, and what corroboration is required for such circumstantial evidence. RULING: The Supreme Court held that the "last seen together" theory is a piece of circumstantial evidence that creates a logical link in the chain, but it cannot alone be the basis for conviction. The proximity of time between "last seen together" and the discovery of the offence must be very close for the inference of guilt to arise. If other explanations for the events are equally plausible, the "last seen" evidence fails. The prosecution must complete the chain of circumstantial evidence to the degree of moral certainty that excludes every hypothesis other than guilt of the accused. REASONING: Last seen theory is circumstantial evidence — it cannot alone sustain conviction. The chain of circumstances must be complete, consistent only with guilt, and exclude every hypothesis of innocence. SIGNIFICANCE: Last seen theory = weak alone. Circumstantial evidence must form complete chain. Classic principle applied in POCSO cases. Compare with Anjan Kumar Sarma v. State of Assam (same principle).