Romesh Thappar v State of Madras

Supreme Court · AIR 1950 SC 124 · 1950-05-26

Bench: Patanjali Sastri J, Fazl Ali J, Mukherjea J, Das J, Aiyar J (majority); Mahajan J (dissent)

Constitutional Law — Freedom of Press — Article 19(1)(a) — First Amendment

FACTS: Romesh Thappar was the printer and publisher of "Cross Roads", a weekly journal printed in Bombay and circulated in Madras. The Madras Government banned the entry and circulation of the journal under the Madras Maintenance of Public Order Act 1949 on grounds of public safety. ISSUE: Whether banning a newspaper on grounds of public safety/order falls within permissible restrictions under Article 19(2) as it originally stood. RULING: Freedom of speech and expression includes the freedom of the press. The Madras Act restricted circulation on grounds of "public order" which was not a permissible restriction under the original Article 19(2) — the only permissible grounds then were security of India and public order in relation to foreign states. The restriction was void. REASONING: Freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) includes freedom of the press. Restrictions must fall strictly within the grounds enumerated in Article 19(2) — courts cannot expand those grounds. SIGNIFICANCE: This judgment prompted the First Constitutional Amendment (1951) which added "public order" as a permissible restriction under Article 19(2). Critical for understanding evolution of Article 19(2).

Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam

All court updates