Representation Of People Act Doesn't Apply To Municipal Elections, But False Affidavits Can Still Attract IPC: Supreme Court
Supreme Court · 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 650 · 2026-07-01
Bench: Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh
Election
FACTS: The appellant, Chandrikaben Kishor Dafda, had contested the 2015 municipal elections in Gujarat. A complaint alleged that she suppressed details of immovable property owned by her husband in the affidavit she filed along with her nomination papers, as required under election rules. A Magistrate took cognizance and summoned her under Section 125A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 ("RPA"), which penalises the filing of a false affidavit by a candidate. Dafda challenged the proceedings, contending that Section 125A of the RPA — a central enactment governing elections to Parliament and the State Legislatures — could not be invoked in respect of a municipal election, which is a creature of, and governed by, separate state municipal legislation. ISSUE: Whether the penal provision under Section 125A of the RPA, 1951, which criminalises false declarations in election affidavits, applies to candidates contesting municipal or local body elections; and, if not, whether such candidates escape all criminal liability for filing false affidavits. RULING: The Supreme Court held that the RPA's own definition of "election" in Section 2(d) confines the statute's application to elections to Parliament and the State Legislatures, and that municipal elections — being governed by separate state enactments such as the Gujarat Municipalities Act — fall outside its scope. Consequently, Section 125A of the RPA could not have been invoked against Dafda. However, the Court clarified this is not a free pass: since the Gujarat Municipalities Act no longer contains a penal provision for false affidavits (having been omitted by amendment in 1990), a candidate who files a false declaration can instead be prosecuted under the general provisions of the Indian Penal Code dealing with false statements and false evidence. Because the Magistrate had taken cognizance under the wrong statutory provision, the Court treated this as a curable irregularity under the Code of Criminal Procedure rather than a ground to quash the proceedings outright, and remanded the matter for the correct provision of law to be applied. REASONING: The Bench read the RPA's definitional provision strictly, holding that a penal statute cannot be stretched to cover a field the legislature did not intend it to occupy, however desirable it might be from a policy standpoint to have uniform false-affidavit penalties across all tiers of elections. At the same time, the Court was unwilling to let a candidate escape scrutiny entirely merely because the wrong label had been used at the cognizance stage; taking cognizance under a mistaken provision, the Court held, is an irregularity curable under Section 465 CrPC so long as no failure of justice results. On the scope of disclosure itself, the Court also held — while examining the affidavit requirements — that the obligation to disclose assets extends to those held by "myself, my spouse, and dependents," meaning immovable property solely and separately owned by a candidate's spouse must also be disclosed, not merely jointly-held or dependent-linked assets. SIGNIFICANCE: This judgment sharply distinguishes the criminal-law architecture applicable to parliamentary and assembly elections from that applicable to municipal and panchayat-level elections — a distinction with real consequences given how frequently false-affidavit allegations arise in local body polls. It is a useful illustration, for exam purposes, of strict construction of penal statutes, the "curable irregularity" doctrine under the CrPC/BNSS framework, and the expansive reading given to asset-disclosure obligations for candidates' spouses in election law. Students preparing for judiciary and CLAT examinations should note this case alongside other RPA disqualification and affidavit-disclosure precedents as a cluster of election-law topics that recur frequently in current-affairs based questions.
Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam, CLAT