N.G. Dastane v S. Dastane
Supreme Court · AIR 1975 SC 1534 · 1975-03-15
Bench: Y.V. Chandrachud J, P.N. Bhagwati J, P.K. Goswami J
Family Law — Matrimonial Cruelty — Hindu Marriage Act — Standard of Proof
FACTS: Dr N.G. Dastane sought a divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of cruelty. He alleged that his wife had made false complaints against him, threatened to kill him, and quarrelled continuously. The wife denied cruelty. The question arose: what standard of proof applies in matrimonial proceedings? ISSUE: What is the standard of proof in matrimonial proceedings; what constitutes cruelty under the Hindu Marriage Act. RULING: In matrimonial proceedings, the standard of proof is preponderance of probabilities (civil standard), not beyond reasonable doubt (criminal standard). Cruelty does not have to be physical — persistent mental harassment, repeated false accusations, conduct that makes the petitioner's life miserable, constitutes cruelty. Divorce on grounds of cruelty was granted. REASONING: Standard of proof in matrimonial cases is on a balance of probabilities. "Cruelty" under Section 10 HMA includes mental cruelty — conduct that endangers mental health or makes it unreasonable to expect parties to live together. SIGNIFICANCE: Civil standard (balance of probabilities) in matrimonial cases. Mental cruelty now a ground for divorce (Section 13(1)(ia) HMA). Foundation for subsequent cruelty cases.
Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam