M/S LTD. v. NEERU DEVI
Supreme Court · CRL.A. NO. 014758-014758 - 2025 · 2026-08-20
Bench: Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice K. Vinod Chandran
Taxation — Direct & Indirect
FACTS: The Supreme Court in M/s National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Neeru Devi & Ors. (Civil Appeal arising from SLP(C) No. 19462/2025) allowed the insurer’s appeal and halved the compensation awarded for the 2017 death of a transport contractor, holding that monthly income of ₹95,000 was inferred without evidence and that the business income from two trucks would not cease with his death. Rejecting reliance on Gurpreet Kaur v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1778 where a young tractor-owning contractor’s income was proved through promptly cleared EMIs, the Court distinguished that here no income-tax returns were filed, 15 EMI defaults existed, and the trucks could continue to ply under hired drivers, so the family did not lose the business stream. Applying the Constitution Bench principle in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 that compensation must neither be a windfall nor a pittance, it fixed loss of dependency at ₹50 lakh (half the Tribunal’s figure) on the ₹50 lakh already deposited, ordered 9 % interest from claim-petition date, and awarded additional ₹1.6 lakh collectively for consortium, estate and funeral expenses, holding children also entitled to filial consortium per Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram (2018) 18 SCC 130; the balance must be paid within one month. ISSUE: Legal question arising in taxation — direct & indirect RULING: The Supreme Court in M/s National Insurance Co. SIGNIFICANCE: Allowed