Manohar Lal v. Commissioner of Police

Supreme Court · EL-SC-2026-03-032 · 12-03-2026

Bench: J.K. Maheshwari; Atul S. Chandurkar

Service law

FACTS: The Supreme Court (March 12) observed that the power to dismiss a government servant from service without holding a departmental enquiry cannot be exercised on mere presumption that conducting such an enquiry is not reasonably practicable. The Court added that the decision of the authority to dispense with the requirement of holding an enquiry before dismissing a government servant should be supported by some material. Maheshwari and Atul S. Chandurkar heard an appeal filed by the Delhi police constable, who was dismissed from service without holding a departmental enquiry on the presumption of the Deputy Commissioner of Police (DCP) that conducting such an enquiry would not be reasonably practicable, as the appellant, facing a criminal trial, might threaten or intimidate witnesses. ISSUE: Whether to Dismiss Public Servant Without Dept Enquiry Sufficient Cause Must Be Shown Supreme Court Reinstantes Delhi Police Officer? RULING: The Supreme Court (March 12) observed that the power to dismiss a government servant from service without holding a departmental enquiry cannot be exercised on mere presumption that conducting such an enquiry is not reasonably practicable. SIGNIFICANCE: Remember: Service law; Article 311(2) of the Constitution; To Dismiss Public Servant Without Dept Enquiry Sufficient Cause Must Be Shown Supreme Court Reinstantes Delhi Police Officer. DISSENT: No dissent recorded.

Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam

All court updates