Mandal Commission Case
Supreme Court · 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 · 1992-11-16
Bench: 9-judge bench: Sawant J, Kuldip Singh J, Pandian J, Thommen J, Jeevan Reddy J, Agrawal J (majority); Mukherjee CJ, Venkatachaliah J, Ahmadi J (partial dissent on some aspects)
Constitutional Law — OBC Reservations — Creamy Layer — 50% Cap — Article 16(4)
FACTS: The V.P. Singh Government implemented the Mandal Commission report and issued an Office Memorandum in 1990 reserving 27% government jobs for Other Backward Classes (OBCs). The government also separately reserved 10% seats for economically backward sections of higher castes. The orders were challenged. ISSUE: Validity of 27% OBC reservation; whether creamy layer should be excluded; whether reservations can apply to promotions; 50% cap. RULING: The 27% reservation for OBCs is constitutionally valid under Article 16(4). Total reservation cannot exceed 50% (the "50% rule"). The creamy layer — the socially advanced sections of OBCs — must be excluded from reservations. Reservations cannot apply to promotions in government service. Economic criterion alone cannot be the basis for reservations under Article 16(4). The 10% economic reservation for upper castes was struck down. REASONING: Article 16(4) provides for reservation as an enabling provision for adequate representation. Total reservations must not ordinarily exceed 50%. Creamy layer exclusion is mandatory. Caste can be the primary criterion for backwardness, but economic criterion alone is insufficient. SIGNIFICANCE: Most important reservation case. 9-judge bench. Key ratios: 50% ceiling, creamy layer exclusion, no reservations in promotions (subsequently amended by 77th/85th Amendments), economic criterion alone insufficient. EWS 103rd Amendment (2019) was later upheld in Janhit Abhiyan (2022) — added Article 15(6)/16(6).
Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam