LEGISLATIVE LUCKNOW v. SUSHIL KUMAR
Supreme Court · CRL.A. NO. 011842-011842 - 2025 · 2026-08-20
Bench: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Vijay Bishnoi
Criminal Law — General
FACTS: The High Court's order for a CBI inquiry into the recruitment process for various posts in the Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council Secretariat lacked justification, as it did not meet the high threshold required for such actions. Mere allegations or doubts are insufficient for a CBI investigation; clear evidence of serious criminal offenses is needed. The High Court based its order on vague concerns and "inexplicable details" from the external recruitment agency's master data without specifying the issues. This did not meet the necessary criteria, especially as the original petitioners did not request a CBI inquiry. The order for the CBI inquiry was set aside, and the High Court was instructed to consider the special appeal on its merits. ISSUE: Legal question arising in criminal law — general RULING: The High Court's order for a CBI inquiry into the recruitment process for various posts in the Uttar Pradesh Legislative Council Secretariat lacked justification, as it did not meet the high threshold required for such actions. SIGNIFICANCE: Set Aside
Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam