KIMBERLEY LTD. v. KRISHI PARISHAD

Supreme Court · C.A. NO. 013111-013111 - 2025 · 2025-10-31

Bench: Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi

Taxation — Direct & Indirect

FACTS: The rejection of the appellant's technical bid was based on the claim that the 'haisiyat praman patra' was not issued by the District Magistrate; however, the tender notice did not specify this requirement. The valuation certificate provided by the appellant, issued by a qualified valuer registered with the Income Tax Department, met the tender requirements. The matter is remanded to the Mandi Parishad to reconsider the appellant's technical bid, taking into account the asset valuation disclosed in the submitted certificate. ISSUE: Legal question arising in taxation — direct & indirect RULING: The rejection of the appellant's technical bid was based on the claim that the 'haisiyat praman patra' was not issued by the District Magistrate; however, the tender notice did not specify this requirement. SIGNIFICANCE: Remanded

All court updates