GOVIND v. STATE HARYANA
Supreme Court · C.A. NO. 005641-005641 - 2024 · 2025-11-14
Bench: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Vijay Bishnoi
Criminal Law — General
FACTS: The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant of murder under Section 302 IPC and Arms Act Section 25, holding that conviction founded solely on recovery of an unlicensed pistol and FSL report, absent credible evidence that the weapon was used in the crime, is untenable; the decisive infirmities were that the sole purported eyewitness and first responder turned hostile, no last-seen or identification evidence survived, the pistol was seized from an unlocked iron box in a shared dwelling without independent witnesses, the chain of custody from malkhana to FSL remained unproved, and the alleged motive (quid pro quo with co-accused who were either discharged or acquitted) was speculative. Distinguishing State of Himachal Pradesh v. Jeet Singh (1999) 4 SCC 370 and State of Maharashtra v. Bharat Fakira Dhiwar (2002) 1 SCC 622 where recoveries inside exclusive premises were corroborated by strong circumstances, the Court applied Manjunath v. State of Karnataka (2023) SCC OnLine SC 1421 and Jaikam Khan v. State of U.P. (2021) 13 SCC 716 to hold that objects recovered from places accessible to others, without distinct nexus to the offence, cannot sustain guilt; disclosure statements per Section 27 Evidence Act are irrelevant when the "fact discovered" is not shown to be the crime weapon. The appeal was allowed, convictions set aside, and the appellant directed to be released forthwith. ISSUE: Whether the offence amounts to murder under Section 302 IPC or culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 IPC? RULING: The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant of murder under Section 302 IPC and Arms Act Section 25, holding that conviction founded solely on recovery of an unlicensed pistol and FSL report, absent credible evidence that the weapon was used in the crime, is untenable; the decisive infirmities were that the sole purported eyewitness and first responder turned hostile, no last-seen or identification evidence survived, the pistol was seized from an unlocked iron box in a shared dwelling without independent witnesses, the chain of custody from malkhana to FSL remained unproved, and the alleged motive (quid pro quo with co-accused who were either discharged or acquitted) was speculative. SIGNIFICANCE: Distinction between murder (S.302) and culpable homicide not amounting to murder (S.304) IPC
Exam relevance: Judiciary Exam