“No Added Sugar” Row: Delhi HC Stays FSSAI’s Britannia Order

Landmark Judgements
Can a biscuit maker tell you what isn’t in the box, or does doing so automatically become an attack on every competitor who hasn’t said the same? That question landed before the Delhi High Court this October, and its interim answer could reshape how food labels across India are drafted, reviewed, and litigated. Title: “No Added Sugar” Isn’t an Advertisement, Says Delhi HC — FSSAI’s Britannia Crackdown Put on Hold Case Name: Britannia Industries Limited v. Food Safety and Standards Authority of India & Ors. Case Number: W.P.(C) 15649/2026 with CM APPL. 73345/2026 and CM APPL. 73346/2026 Court: High Court of Delhi at New Delhi Judges: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amit Mahajan Judgment Date: 16 October 2026 Citation: CNR No. DLHC010509282026; [2026] Del HC (unreported, interim order) ABSTRACT This case analysis examines the Delhi High Court’s interim order staying a Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) directive that required Britannia Industries to strip the claims “No Added Sugar,” “No Maida,” and “No Palm Oil” from its biscuit and cookie labels. FSSAI’s underlying show-cause notice had invoked Regulation 6(1) of the Food Safety and Standards (Advertising and Claims) Regulations, 2018, arguing that such “non-addition” claims implicitly paint the omitted ingredients as unsafe or inferior, thereby disparaging competing products and swaying consumer choice in violation of Regulations 4(1) and 10(5). Justice Amit Mahajan, on a prima facie assessment, held that statements accurately describing a product’s actual composition are factual declarations rather than comparative advertisements, and therefore cannot, without more, be treated as misleading or disparaging. The analysis situates this order within the broader jurisprudence on comparative advertising, disparagement, and the Consumer Protection Act, 2019’s treatment of misleading claims, and considers what the ruling signals for food businesses navigating India’s increasingly health-conscious labelling environment — while cautioning that the relief is interim, the matter remains sub judice, and the next hearing is scheduled for 15 January 2027. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction and Background Facts of the Case Regulatory Framework Invoked by FSSAI Arguments Advanced by Britannia Industries The Court’s Reasoning and Interim Findings Relevant Precedents on Comparative Advertising and Disparagement Implications for Food Labelling and Consumer Protection Law Conclusion and Way Forward INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND India’s packaged food sector has, over the last several years, leaned heavily on “free-from” marketing — labels that announce what a product does not contain rather than simply listing what it does. “No Added Sugar,” “No Maida,” “No Palm Oil,” “Zero Trans Fat,” and similar phrases have become a shorthand language between health-conscious consumers and manufacturers competing for shelf space. The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), as the statutory regulator under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, has simultaneously grown more assertive in policing this language, concerned that absence-claims can function as backdoor disparagement of rival products that do contain the named ingredient. The Delhi High Court’s order in Britannia Industries Limited v. FSSAI sits exactly at this friction point, and because Britannia is one of India’s largest biscuit manufacturers, the outcome is being watched closely by the wider FMCG and legal-compliance community as a potential bellwether for how “non-addition” claims will be treated going forward. FACTS OF THE CASE The dispute traces back to a show-cause notice issued by FSSAI on 2 September 2026, asking Britannia to explain why the claims “100% Millets,” “No Added Sugar,” “No Maida,” and “No Palm Oil” — appearing on the packaging of its NutriChoice Millets Cookies — should not be declared misleading and impermissible under Regulation 6(1) of the Food Safety and Standards (Advertising and Claims) Regulations, 2018. Following this notice, FSSAI issued a communication dated 9 October 2026 directing Britannia to remove or discontinue all four claims from its product labels. Britannia approached the Delhi High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, challenging the 9 October communication as arbitrary and legally unsustainable, while making a calculated concession: it agreed to drop the “100% Millets” claim from its packaging — without conceding that the underlying factual assertion was untrue — in order to narrow the dispute to the three ingredient-absence claims it considered genuinely defensible. REGULATORY FRAMEWORK INVOKED BY FSSAI FSSAI’s objection rested on a cluster of provisions within the Food Safety and Standards (Advertising and Claims) Regulations, 2018. Regulation 6(1), the central provision cited in the show-cause notice, restricts advertisements and claims that could mislead consumers about the true nature, substance, or quality of a food product. FSSAI’s position, as recorded in the proceedings, was that declaring an ingredient absent necessarily implies that the ingredient is undesirable, unsafe, or inferior when present — an implication it said unfairly colours consumer perception of competitors’ products that do use sugar, maida, or palm oil. FSSAI additionally invoked Regulation 4(1), which prohibits claims undermining other manufacturers’ products, and Regulation 10(5), which addresses claims capable of influencing consumer purchasing behaviour through comparison. Read together, FSSAI’s theory treated the three claims less as product descriptions and more as comparative advertisements directed, even if silently, against every biscuit on the shelf that does contain these ingredients. ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY BRITANNIA INDUSTRIES Appearing for Britannia, Senior Advocate Sandeep Sethi built the petitioner’s case around a single, sharply drawn distinction: a factual statement is not an advertisement in the regulatory sense, however commercially convenient that statement might be. Counsel submitted that “No Added Sugar,” “No Maida,” and “No Palm Oil” are verifiable statements of fact about the product’s actual ingredient composition — not value judgments about competing products. On this reading, FSSAI’s objection conflated truthful disclosure with disparagement, two legally distinct categories under advertising and consumer-protection jurisprudence. Britannia further argued that nothing in the three claims expressly or impliedly referenced any named or identifiable competitor, a threshold ordinarily required before a claim can be characterised as comparative advertising capable of undermining “other manufacturers’ products.” The concession on “100% Millets” was framed as a pragmatic narrowing of the dispute, not an admission of wrongdoing — Britannia maintained its product did in fact contain 100% millets, but chose not to press that specific claim before the Court at this interim stage. THE COURT’S REASONING AND INTERIM FINDINGS Justice Amit Mahajan’s order proceeds on a prima facie basis, as is customary at the interim-relief stage, but the reasoning is nonetheless instructive. The Court agreed with Britannia’s core submission that stating the fact that a product contains “No Added Sugar,” “No Maida,” and “No Palm Oil” cannot, on its own, be treated as an advertisement that undermines other manufacturers or improperly influences consumer behaviour within the meaning of the 2018 Regulations. This framing matters: the Court did not hold that ingredient-absence claims can never be misleading, nor did it strike down FSSAI’s regulatory authority to scrutinise such claims. It held, instead, that truthfulness is the operative variable — a claim grounded in verified product composition occupies a different legal category from a claim engineered to disparage. Having reached this prima facie view, the Court stayed the 9 October 2026 communication, permitted Britannia to continue producing and marketing its NutriChoice Millets Cookies while retaining the three contested claims, but recorded Britannia’s own concession that the product would be marketed without the separate “100% Millets” claim. Notice was issued to FSSAI and the other respondents, and the matter has been listed for further hearing on 15 January 2027 — meaning the final word on the legality of the claims is still to come. RELEVANT PRECEDENTS ON COMPARATIVE ADVERTISING AND DISPARAGEMENT The Court’s fact-versus-disparagement framework does not emerge in a vacuum; it tracks a line of Indian jurisprudence on comparative advertising built up largely outside the food-regulatory space but routinely imported into it. In Horlicks Ltd. & Anr. v. Heinz India Pvt. Ltd., the Delhi High Court laid down governing principles for assessing disparagement in comparative advertising, holding that a manufacturer is entitled to boast about its own product, including by comparison, so long as it does not denigrate or discredit a competitor’s product through false or misleading statements. Similarly, in Reckitt Benckiser (India) Ltd. v. Naga Ltd. & Ors., the Calcutta High Court articulated the now widely cited test distinguishing permissible “puffery” from actionable disparagement, turning on whether the impugned claim makes a false or misleading statement of fact about a rival’s goods, as opposed to a general assertion of superiority or absence. Food-sector regulators have also had to reckon with this line of reasoning in matters such as PepsiCo India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. FSSAI before the Bombay High Court, which examined FSSAI’s power to restrict “no added preservative” and similar absence-based claims under packaging and labelling regulations, underscoring that regulatory restrictions on food labels must still be tested against principles of reasonableness and factual accuracy rather than blanket prohibition. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019, particularly its definition of “misleading advertisement” under Section 2(28), supplies the complementary consumer-facing standard: a claim is misleading only if it gives a false description of the goods or conveys an express or implied representation which, if made by the manufacturer, would be false or misleading. Read alongside these authorities, the Delhi High Court’s approach in the Britannia matter is consistent with the broader doctrinal position that accuracy, not the mere fact of comparison or omission-highlighting, is the touchstone of legality. IMPLICATIONS FOR FOOD LABELLING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LAW Even as an interim order, this ruling carries practical weight for compliance teams across the FMCG sector. First, it signals that FSSAI’s enforcement of Regulation 6(1) cannot rest on the bare premise that any absence-claim is inherently disparaging; the regulator will need to demonstrate that a specific claim is factually inaccurate, or that it targets an identifiable competitor, before an order of removal can survive judicial scrutiny. Second, the order reinforces that manufacturers retain considerable latitude to communicate genuine product composition to increasingly label-literate consumers, provided the underlying claims are verifiable and not dressed up with embellishments such as “100%” superlatives that invite closer scrutiny — a distinction the Court implicitly drew by treating the “100% Millets” claim differently from the three ingredient-absence claims. Third, the decision arrives amid a wider wave of similar litigation, including disputes involving ITC’s “100% Atta” claims and Dabur’s “100% Pure” and “100% Natural” labelling, suggesting that Indian courts are, for the moment, inclined to favour disclosure-based reasoning over precautionary regulatory bans, at least at the interim stage. For consumers, the central tension remains unresolved: does “No Added Sugar” genuinely inform a health-conscious choice, or does it subtly condition the market against products that are, in fact, equally safe but formulated differently? That question will likely only be settled once the Delhi High Court delivers its final ruling after the 15 January 2027 hearing, and potentially only after appellate scrutiny. CONCLUSION AND WAY FORWARD The Delhi High Court’s interim order in Britannia Industries Limited v. FSSAI is best read as a cautious, fact-centric recalibration rather than a final verdict on the legality of ingredient-absence labelling. By distinguishing truthful compositional disclosure from disparaging comparative advertising, Justice Amit Mahajan has, at least provisionally, preserved manufacturers’ ability to state plain facts about their products while leaving FSSAI’s broader regulatory concerns about consumer perception open for full adjudication. The case now moves toward its next hearing on 15 January 2027, where the Court will need to engage more deeply with whether Regulations 4(1), 6(1), and 10(5) of the 2018 Regulations permit FSSAI to look beyond literal truth and regulate the psychological effect of a claim on consumer choice. Until then, food manufacturers would be well advised to ensure that any “No Added,” “Zero,” or “100%” claim on their packaging is backed by verifiable laboratory data and worded with precision, since the durability of this interim relief — and any claim built on its reasoning — will ultimately depend on how the final order addresses the deeper question FSSAI has raised: whether telling the truth about an absence can still, in substance, be an attack on everyone who hasn’t made the same claim.

Browse the EduLaw legal blog