MP High Court Orders Police to Produce Women Detained at Itarsi for CJP Protest | Habeas Corpus

Legal Updates
The Madhya Pradesh High Court issued habeas corpus directions after two women Shravani Buva and Preeti Prashant Lodhe were forcibly removed from a train at Itarsi and detained without disclosure of their whereabouts. CJ Alpesh Y. Kogje's Bench ordered their production before the Court. On October 9, 2026, the Madhya Pradesh High Court stepped in after two women activists disappeared into police custody at Itarsi Junction railway station with no official word to their families about where they were being held. The division bench of Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje and Justice Vivek Jain heard urgent habeas corpus petitions filed by the families of Shravani Buva and Preeti Prashant Lodhe and directed the State of Madhya Pradesh and its police authorities to produce both women before the Court on or before October 13, 2026. The Court also left open the option for the State to arrange the safe return of the two women to their respective families before the returnable date, provided prior notice was given to the petitioners. The detention arose from a sweeping police operation across Madhya Pradesh aimed at intercepting protesters heading to Delhi for the Cockroach Janta Party's October 10 demonstration at Jantar Mantar. The CJP had called for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over allegations of irregularities in the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. Buva, who serves as the Pune District Convener of the All India Students' Federation, was travelling aboard the Goa Express with approximately 22 fellow activists when the Government Railway Police removed them from the train at Itarsi. Reports indicate that an initial attempt to deboard Buva and another activist, Niharika Bhosale, at Bhusawal Junction in Maharashtra was resisted by the group, but the police succeeded in removing them once the train reached Itarsi in Madhya Pradesh. The habeas corpus petition filed on behalf of one of the detainees alleged that the woman was physically assaulted by the police during the deboarding and had been held at an undisclosed location since October 8, 2026, with her family receiving no official communication about her whereabouts. This absence of information about the place of custody formed the core of the constitutional grievance. Under Article 22 of the Indian Constitution, every person who is arrested must be informed of the grounds of arrest and must not be denied the right to consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of their choice. The failure to communicate the place of detention to the family raises serious questions about compliance with the procedural safeguards laid down by the Supreme Court in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997), which mandate that the next of kin of an arrested person must be informed of the arrest and the place of custody. The legal basis invoked by the police was Section 172 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, which requires persons to conform to lawful directions of the police. A high-ranking GRP officer confirmed to The Hindu that the students were detained on October 8 under this provision and taken to a private hotel. However, Section 172 presupposes that the underlying police direction is itself lawful. When a GRP officer at Itarsi was asked whether citizens require permission to attend a protest, the officer reportedly replied, "Of course, they do. There has to be a system to stop all this. And we acted as per the orders we received." This statement, widely reported in the media, exposes a fundamental misunderstanding of constitutional law. The right to peaceful assembly under Article 19(1)(b) of the Constitution does not require individual citizens to obtain police permission before travelling to attend a lawful gathering. The High Court's operative order was precise in its language. The Bench directed: "Issue notice, making it returnable on 13.10.2026. The State is directed to produce the corpus before this Court. It is also open for the State to produce the corpus before the Court prior to the returnable date with the prior notice to the other side. However, it is also open for the State to make an arrangement for safe return of the corpus to the respective family. Stand over to 13.10.2026." By using the term "corpus" — the body of the person in whose name the habeas corpus writ is sought — the Court underscored the gravity of the matter. The State was put on clear notice that the physical production of the detained women, or their verifiable safe return home, was non-negotiable. The Itarsi detentions were not an isolated incident. Additional Advocate General Bramhadatt Singh, upon learning of the habeas corpus petitions, immediately issued communications to the Director General of Police, the Superintendent of Police of Narmadapuram, the Itarsi Station House Officer, and the Superintendent of Police (Railways), Bhopal, directing them to take steps to comply with the Court's directions and avoid adverse consequences. Across Madhya Pradesh, police intercepted protesters at Bhopal, Itarsi, and Gwalior railway stations. A senior police officer told The Indian Express that at least 30 protesters had been removed from trains and detained, with officers citing "orders from above" as the justification. The CJP also reported that seven activists from Telangana and Andhra Pradesh were forcibly deboarded by railway police at Bhopal and Gwalior, with their whereabouts remaining unknown. This case brings into sharp focus the constitutional limits on preventive police action against citizens who are merely travelling to participate in a political demonstration. The writ of habeas corpus is the most potent constitutional remedy against unlawful detention, described by the Supreme Court as the "first security of civil liberty." Its invocation in this instance signals that the judiciary is unwilling to look the other way when the State detains citizens without lawful authority and then conceals their place of custody from their families. The right to know where a detained person is being held is not a procedural formality it is the very foundation of the rule of law, because a person hidden from judicial and family oversight is a person at risk of abuse. The matter is now listed for October 13, 2026, and the legal community will be watching closely to see whether the State complies with the Court's direction. If the women are produced before the Court, the next stage of proceedings will likely examine the legality of the detention itself, the statutory authority under which it was carried out, and whether the police had any reasonable basis to believe that the mere act of boarding a train to attend a protest constituted a ground for preventive custody. The outcome of this case could set an important precedent for the limits of State power in intercepting citizens en route to exercise their fundamental right of peaceful assembly. Case Details at a Glance Court: Madhya Pradesh High Court (Principal Bench, Jabalpur) Bench: Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje and Justice Vivek Jain Case Type: Habeas Corpus Petition Detainees: Shravani Buva and Preeti Prashant Lodhe Date of Detention: October 8, 2026 Date of Hearing: October 9, 2026 Next Date: October 13, 2026 Key Provisions: Article 19(1)(b), Article 21, Article 22 of the Constitution of India; Section 172, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Key Precedents Engaged: D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997); Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P. (1994); Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018)

Browse the EduLaw legal blog