Extramarital Affair Not Cruelty Under 498A? Madras HC Explains
EduLaw EditorialLandmark JudgementsDoes a husband’s affair make him a criminal under Section 498A? The Madras High Court says a proved illicit relationship is not enough. The prosecution must show something more. Here is what the ruling means for matrimonial cases. Case Name: T. Deivakumar v. The State, represented by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Udumalpet Sub Division, Tirupur, and Another Case Number: Crl.A. No. 599 of 2018 Court: Madras High Court Judges: Justice Sunder Mohan Judgment Date: October 8, 2026 (reported October 23, 2026) Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 509 Opening hook: A husband’s affair can break a marriage. But can it, on its own, send him to prison for cruelty? In October 2026 the Madras High Court answered with a careful no. Betrayal is not automatically a crime under Section 498A. ABSTRACT This case analysis examines the Madras High Court’s decision in T. Deivakumar v. The State. The court dismissed an appeal by a deceased woman’s brother against the acquittal of her husband under Sections 498A and 306 of the Indian Penal Code. The court disagreed with the trial court on two findings. It held that the illicit relationship was in fact proved, and that rejecting it merely because the other woman was not examined was perverse. Even so, it held that an extramarital relationship, by itself, is not cruelty under Section 498A. Something more must be shown, such as conduct likely to drive the wife to suicide or harassment linked to an unlawful demand. The dowry allegation was held to be an improvement on the earliest version of events. The ruling is useful for law students, litigators and anyone studying how courts separate marital misconduct from criminal liability. TABLE OF CONTENTS Case Snapshot and Background How the Case Travelled: Trial Court to High Court The Legal Questions Before the Court Arguments of the Appellant and the Husband The Court’s Reasoning on the Affair and Section 498A Why the Dowry Allegation Failed Precedents That Shape the Ruling Critical Analysis and Contrasting Views Impact on Matrimonial and Criminal Practice Conclusion Frequently Asked Questions 1. CASE SNAPSHOT AND BACKGROUND The couple married on 14 September 2008. The prosecution alleged that the wife was harassed over a dowry demand around Diwali. It also alleged that the husband had a relationship with another woman and neglected his wife. On 3 November 2010, about two years after the marriage, she died by suicide. One report states that she jumped into water along with her one-and-a-half-year-old child, but that detail appears in only one source, so please check it against the judgment. Her brother first lodged a “woman missing” complaint, registered as Crime No. 994 of 2010. After investigation, the police filed a final report against the husband under Section 498A and Section 306 of the IPC . 2. HOW THE CASE TRAVELLED: TRIAL COURT TO HIGH COURT The Fast Track Mahila Court, Tiruppur, heard the case as S.C. No. 31 of 2015. The prosecution examined 11 witnesses and marked 13 exhibits. On 23 April 2018 the trial court acquitted the husband. It found that neither the dowry demand nor the illicit relationship was proved. Because the dowry demand failed, it held that the presumption under Section 113A of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 could not be raised. It also found no evidence of cruelty of a kind that would drive the wife to suicide. The State did not appeal. The wife’s brother, the complainant, did, and the matter reached Justice Sunder Mohan in Crl.A. No. 599 of 2018. 3. THE LEGAL QUESTIONS BEFORE THE COURT Three questions arose. First, was the trial court right to hold that the illicit relationship was not proved? Second, if the relationship was proved, does it by itself amount to “cruelty” under Section 498A ? Third, was the dowry demand established so that the presumption under Section 113A and the charge under Section 306 could stand? The first question was about evidence, the second about the meaning of the statute, and the third about whether the prosecution had met its burden. 4. ARGUMENTS OF THE APPELLANT AND THE HUSBAND The brother argued that the trial court ignored the evidence of the mother and other witnesses about the dowry demand and the affair. He said the mother clearly described cruelty and that the acquittal was therefore perverse. The husband argued that the prosecution had proved neither a dowry demand nor an illicit relationship. Counsel for the appellant was K. Sudhakar. The State was represented by Additional Public Prosecutor Sharada Vivek, and V. Ayyapparaja appeared for the husband. 5. THE COURT’S REASONING ON THE AFFAIR AND SECTION 498A This is the heart of the ruling. The High Court first corrected the trial court. It held that disbelieving the affair only because the other woman was not examined was perverse. The relationship was proved. The court then asked what that proof meant in law, and relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of Gujarat, (2013) 10 SCC 448 . Reading Explanation (a) to Section 498A , which covers wilful conduct likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury to her life, limb or health, the court held that the affair was not of such a nature as to drive the wife to suicide. It observed that to attract Section 498A , the prosecution must establish something more than a mere illicit relationship, and here it had not. 6. WHY THE DOWRY ALLEGATION FAILED Explanation (b) to Section 498A treats harassment aimed at coercing a woman or her relatives to meet an unlawful demand for property as cruelty. The court found the evidence on this point weak. The brother’s original “woman missing” complaint mentioned the alleged illicit relationship but said nothing about dowry. The explanation that the deceased told her mother to hide the demand from the father and brother did not inspire confidence. The villagers who mediated the dispute spoke only of matrimonial differences over the relationship, and their references to dowry were vague. The court held the dowry version to be an improvement on the earliest account. Without a proved dowry demand, the presumption under Section 113A of the Evidence Act was unavailable, even though the death occurred within seven years of marriage. 7. PRECEDENTS THAT SHAPE THE RULING The court expressly relied on Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal v. State of Gujarat (2013) 10 SCC 448 . The following cases are not mentioned in the reports I could access. I have added them as the surrounding law, and you should verify each citation against the official reports before publishing. K.V. Prakash Babu v. State of Karnataka : the Supreme Court held that an extramarital relationship, per se, does not fall within Section 498A. Girdhar Shankar Tawade v. State of Maharashtra (2002) 5 SCC 177 and Mangat Ram v. State of Haryana (2014) 12 SCC 595 : both stress that cruelty must be proved with evidence tied to the statutory explanations. Wazir Chand v. State of Haryana (1989) 1 SCC 244 : courts must not presume abetment merely because a wife died by suicide. Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 39 : the Supreme Court struck down the adultery offence in Section 497 IPC, which reinforces that infidelity is not itself a crime. Chandrappa v. State of Karnataka (2007) 4 SCC 415 : sets out the approach for appeals against acquittal, which the High Court followed in reappraising the evidence. 8. CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND CONTRASTING VIEWS The judgment is notable for its two-step method. It corrected the trial court’s errors but still upheld the acquittal, because an appellate court does not reverse simply because it would have reasoned differently. The main point of debate is the contrast with an earlier Madras High Court ruling, Nakkeeran @ Jeroan Pandy v. State (2022 LiveLaw (Mad) 40) , decided on 7 December 2021 by Justice Chakravarthy. There the court upheld a conviction because the husband’s relationship caused serious domestic discord and mental cruelty, while reducing the sentence. The two decisions can be reconciled on facts. In Nakkeeran the evidence showed that the affair produced sustained mental torment. In Deivakumar the prosecution showed no such link to suicide or harassment. The lesson is that the outcome turns on evidence of effect, not on the existence of the affair. Critics may say this sets a high bar for wives in unhappy marriages. Supporters will say it protects accused persons from conviction on moral disapproval alone. 9. IMPACT ON MATRIMONIAL AND CRIMINAL PRACTICE For prosecutors, the message is to build the case around the statutory explanations, not around the affair. They should lead evidence of conduct that pushed the woman towards suicide or of coercive harassment, and should record dowry allegations in the first complaint. For defence lawyers, discrepancies between the first complaint and later testimony remain a powerful tool, as the dowry finding shows. For family courts, an affair may still support grounds for divorce, which is a civil remedy with a different standard. Note also that the IPC has been replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 . The corresponding provisions are generally Sections 85 and 86 (cruelty) and Section 108 (abetment of suicide), and the Evidence Act presumption now sits in the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 . Please confirm the exact section numbers before publishing, since this case arose under the old IPC. 10. CONCLUSION The Madras High Court has drawn a clear boundary. An affair is a breach of marital trust, but it becomes criminal cruelty under Section 498A only when the evidence shows conduct of the kind the statute describes. By rejecting a shortcut from “affair” to “cruelty” while still correcting the trial court’s errors, Justice Sunder Mohan gave a balanced and fact-driven ruling that students and practitioners can cite with confidence. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS Is an extramarital affair cruelty under Section 498A? Not by itself. The Madras High Court held that the prosecution must prove something more than the relationship. Why was the husband acquitted even though the affair was proved? The court found the affair was not of a nature to drive the wife to suicide, and the dowry demand was not established. Does the ruling apply under the BNS? The reasoning should carry over, since the BNS provisions are substantially similar, but check the new section numbers.